Team Cognitive Health playbook/Module 2 · Critical thinking

Day 12 / 100 · Critical thinking · Claims and evidence

Every claim needs a receipt.

Opinions, stories and data all have a place, but they aren't equal. Name which one you're holding before you act on it.

Opinion

“I Think…”

  • A starting point, not a conclusion
  • Ask: what would change your mind?

Anecdote

“A Customer Said…”

  • Real but narrow; great for questions
  • Ask: how often does this happen?

Data

“The Logs Show…”

  • Broader, but check how it was collected
  • Ask: what is this not measuring?

Test

“We Tried It And…”

  • Strongest when it was set up fairly
  • Ask: what else could explain this?

Ask: how do we know?